The Golden Butterfly is a fixed allocation strategy that takes the Permanent Portfolio's all-weather philosophy and adds an extra growth engine: small cap value stocks. The result is a five-asset portfolio that maintains the Permanent Portfolio's defensive character while capturing additional return from one of the most persistent factors in finance.
What Is the Golden Butterfly?
The Golden Butterfly allocates equally across five asset classes, each at 20%:
- 20% U.S. Total Stock Market: broad equity exposure
- 20% Small Cap Value: the factor premium kicker
- 20% Long-Term U.S. Treasury Bonds: deflation hedge
- 20% Short-Term U.S. Treasury Bonds: stability and recession protection
- 20% Gold: inflation hedge
Compared to the Permanent Portfolio (4x25%), the Golden Butterfly adds a fifth sleeve, small cap value, and trims the other four to 20% each, keeping short-term Treasuries in the cash role. This seemingly small change has meaningful implications for long-term returns.
Who Created It?
The Golden Butterfly was developed by Tyler, the anonymous creator of the Portfolio Charts website (portfoliocharts.com). Tyler's extensive analysis of historical portfolio performance across different time periods and withdrawal rates led him to identify this specific five-asset combination as having exceptional consistency of returns, not necessarily the highest returns, but the narrowest range of outcomes across starting dates. Tyler published the Golden Butterfly in the mid-2010s, and it quickly gained a following among the financial independence (FIRE) community.
How Does It Work?
Like all fixed allocation strategies, the Golden Butterfly is refreshingly simple:
- Allocate 20% each to: U.S. total stock market (VTI), small cap value (VBR/VIOV), long-term Treasuries (TLT), short-term Treasuries (SHY), and gold (GLD).
- Rebalance annually or when any allocation drifts significantly from target.
- No tactical signals: the portfolio stays fully invested at the target weights year after year.
The small cap value allocation is the differentiator. The Fama-French three-factor model shows that small cap value stocks have historically earned a premium over the broad market, and this premium has been remarkably persistent across countries and time periods. By dedicating 20% to this factor, the Golden Butterfly captures additional return without adding tactical complexity.
Historical Performance
Based on BestFolio's backtest from January 1985 through October 2026 (41+ years):
- CAGR: ~8.8%
- Maximum Drawdown: -19.3%
- Backtest Period: 41 years
The backtest starts in January 1985, so it runs through the 1987 crash, the dot-com bust, the 2008 financial crisis and the 2022 rate shock. The worst fall, -19.3%, came in 2022, when stocks and bonds dropped together. In the 2008 crisis it fell 18.8%. Over the same 41 years a Classic 60/40 portfolio fell 33.7% at its worst, between October 2007 and March 2009.
| Episode | Golden Butterfly worst fall (%) | Classic 60/40 worst fall (%) |
|---|---|---|
| 1987 crash | -14.0% | -24.0% |
| Dot-com bust (2000 to 2002) | -9.3% | -24.4% |
| 2008 crisis | -18.8% | -33.7% |
| 2022 rate shock | -19.3% | -20.9% |
Each figure is the deepest drop from a previous high during that episode, on daily data from the same two backtests.
The consistency of returns across different starting dates is what truly sets the Golden Butterfly apart: Tyler designed it specifically to minimize the impact of sequence-of-returns risk, making it particularly attractive for retirees and those approaching financial independence.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Excellent risk-adjusted returns: Strong Sharpe and Sortino ratios relative to simplicity.
- Consistent outcomes: Among the best strategies for minimizing sequence-of-returns risk.
- Simple implementation: Five ETFs, annual rebalancing, no signals to follow.
- Factor exposure: Captures the small cap value premium systematically.
- Moderate drawdowns: -19.3% max DD is very manageable for most investors.
Cons
- SCV premium uncertainty: The small cap value premium has been weaker in recent years, and some argue it's been arbitraged away.
- Gold allocation may seem high: 20% in gold is a significant commitment to a non-yielding asset.
- No tactical overlay: Stays fully invested through all market conditions.
- Early years are reconstructed: The small cap value ETF the backtest holds (IWN) only starts in July 2000. Before that it uses DFA's US Small Cap Value fund back to 1993, and Fama-French small value index returns before 1993, which no fund tracked exactly. The other four legs are extended with older funds and index data in the same way.
Try It on BestFolio
The Golden Butterfly is available as a free strategy on BestFolio. Explore the full backtest, compare it against the Permanent Portfolio and other fixed allocations, and see its year-by-year returns across different market environments.
View Golden Butterfly on BestFolio →
Updated 17 October 2026: the backtest used to start in August 2000, when the small cap value ETF it holds began trading. It now reaches back to January 1985, so the figures above replace the earlier 7.9% CAGR and -19.9% worst fall over 25 years.
For a deeper comparison of fixed allocation approaches, check out our analysis: Golden Butterfly vs All Weather vs 60/40.