Skip to content
Important: BestFolio provides information for educational purposes only. Nothing on this site constitutes investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Read full disclaimer
·3 min read·BestFolio Research Team

Updated

AWEA: a leveraged all-weather portfolio that still fell 47.81%

AWEA, which its author expands as All Weather Experimental Adventure, is the second strategy from u/Separate-Ad-9633 in this batch and his third in the catalog. It arrived as part of a public critique of one of our own listings, which is the most useful kind of contribution we get. Here is what the card shows now that it is live.

What the rule does

AWEA is a leveraged all-weather book with 6 sleeves. The departure from the usual pattern is that each sleeve carries its own trend gate rather than the whole portfolio sharing one. A sleeve is either on, holding its leveraged asset, or off.

What happens to a sleeve that switches off is the second departure. Instead of routing the weight into one fixed defensive asset, it walks down a ladder: long Treasuries first, then gold, then intermediate Treasuries, then cash. The point of the ladder is that the defence is not betting everything on a single asset behaving well in the specific crisis you are in.

That is a direct answer to the criticism the author levelled at our RPEA listing, where the defensive leg is TMF alone. If long Treasuries are the thing that is breaking, a TMF-only defence has nowhere to go. The ladder does.

What the card says

MetricAWEA StandardAWEA with Europe100% US Stock Market
CAGR25.72%24.81%11.06%
Sharpe0.830.830.48
Sortino1.401.380.71
Max drawdown-47.81%-44.74%-55.45%
Annualised volatility26.47%25.07%17.36%
Months to recover that drawdown272553
Annual turnover2.33x2.42x0.00x
History on the card55.8 years55.7 years55.7 years
Bar chart comparing CAGR and maximum drawdown depth for AWEA Standard, AWEA with Europe and the 100% US Stock Market benchmark.
Return and worst fall, from the live cards. AWEA starts 1971-02-01 and the US market row is measured over the same dates.

The number that matters is not the CAGR

AWEA Standard fell 46.28% in the October 1987 crash. Less than 3 years later it was down 47.81%, at the October 1990 low, its worst fall on the card, and it took 27 months to get back. That is 2 falls of close to half the book inside 3 years, on a book you are holding precisely because it is supposed to be all weather. The sleeve-level gates and the defensive ladder did not prevent either, and no honest reading of this card should suggest otherwise.

That is shallower than the unlevered US market's 55.45% over the same dates. Sizing this as a core holding because the headline says all weather would be a mistake.

The Europe variant is the interesting row. It gives up 0.91 points of CAGR for a shallower fall, 44.74% against 47.81%, and 25 months under water against 27. Its worst fall is the October 1987 crash, not the 1990 low. On this card the diversification buys about 3 points of drawdown and a little less volatility for the return it costs.

Why the card starts in 1971

The card runs from February 1971, which is 55.7 years. That is deliberate. A window starting in the mid-1990s would put the 1987 crash behind the edge of what you can see, and for a leveraged trend book the 1987 episode is one of the few genuine tests in the record. On this card it is the second worst fall, behind 1990. Showing a shorter, flattering window would make the strategy look better and tell you less.

The usual caveat applies with force here: most of the leveraged funds in this universe did not exist in 1971. The early history is a reconstruction from the underlying indices, not a record of trades anyone could have made.

The useful conclusion

The ladder is a better answer to defensive concentration than a single fixed hedge. But the case for AWEA rests on the mechanism, not on the 25.95%, and the price of admission is a fall of close to half the book, twice between 1987 and 1990.

Corrections

  • : 11 November 2026: between 1975 and 2005 the Europe sleeve now uses a European stock series built from the Ken French data, then Vanguard's European stock fund from 1990, instead of a developed-markets index that was mostly Japan. AWEA with Europe now falls 44.74%, in the October 1987 crash, so the Europe sleeve buys about 3 points of drawdown, not 0.2. Both AWEA columns show the current cards; the US market column is unchanged.
  • : 22 October 2026: Sortino is now measured above cash, see bestfolio.app/changelog
  • : Figures updated to the current cards. Sharpe and UPI are now measured above cash (see bestfolio.app/changelog). Sharpe, Sortino, volatility and turnover now come from the current cards, the US market column is measured over AWEA's own dates from February 1971, and the chart shows the current returns and drawdowns.
  • : The 17 October 2026 restatement moved the card's start to February 1971 and reran it: Standard now returns 25.95% a year, and its worst fall is now the 1990 episode (47.81%, 27 months to repair) rather than the 1987 crash.
  • : Card figures restated on 16 October 2026: early-1990s international and emerging-market history now uses index data instead of two actively managed funds. AWEA Standard now shows 26.32% a year (was 26.05%), so the Europe variant gives up 0.87 points (was 0.60); small moves in Sortino, volatility and turnover, and the chart is redrawn. The 1987 and 1990 falls are unchanged.
  • : Volatility restated on 15 October 2026: the cards now measure it on observed prices, so months rebuilt from monthly data count at their month-end returns instead of as smooth daily steps. AWEA Standard moves from 24.69% to 27.50% and AWEA with Europe from 23.38% to 26.25%. The US market row starts in December 1987, has no rebuilt months and stays at 17.81%.

Past performance does not guarantee future results. Backtested results are hypothetical and do not represent actual trading.

Written with the help of AI tools and reviewed before publication.

Share this article

Data and method

Study dates and assumptions are documented in the article and its revisions. Our current methodology explains the platform's data sources, proxy histories, trade timing and inflation treatment.

  • 5 New Strategies for October

    The October batch is live: 2 leveraged portfolios from r/LETFs, a momentum model that changes speed with the VIX, a five-fund rotation and Keller's Flexible Asset Allocation. The numbers are the ones on the strategy pages.

Explore with tools

Try these strategies on BestFolio

Browse 89 tactical allocation strategies with monthly signals, walk-forward validation, and portfolio blending. Free to start.

Create free account

BestFolio Monthly Briefing

Liked this post? Get a free monthly recap of TAA strategy signals, performance rankings, and market regime updates. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.